volume 1
Philip F. Detweiler, North Carolina Historical Review 39 (1962): 560-61.

volumes 1-2
W. W. Abbot, American Historical Review 68 (1963): 476-78.
Stuart Gerry Brown, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 87 (1963): 101-4.
Lester J. Cappon, American Archivist 26 (1963): 209-10.
William G. Carleton, Political Science Quarterly 78 (1963): 114-16.
John M. Coleman, Journal of Modern History 35 (1963): 178-80.
Noble E. Cunningham Jr., The Historian 25 (1962): 104-5.
Richard Beale Davis, American Literature 35 (1963): 88-89.
Irving Dilliard, Journal of the Illinois State Historical Society 56 (1963): 96-97.
John T. Farrell, Catholic Historical Review 48 (1963): 551-52.
J. Theodore Hefley, American Quarterly 14 (1962): 507-10.
Donald Jackson, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 345 (1963): 164-65.
Merrill Jensen, Wisconsin Magazine of History 47 (1963-64): 175-77.
Albert T. Kohlmeier, Indiana Magazine of History 58 (1962): 373-74.
Leonard W. Levy, Mississippi Valley Historical Review 49 (1962): 504-6.
David J. Mays, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 70 (1962): 488-89.
J. R. Pole, Bulletin of the British Association for American Studies, n.s. 6 (1963): 66-68.
William F. Swindler, American Journal of Legal History 7 (1963): 178-84.
Raymond Walters Jr., William and Mary Quarterly 20 (1963): 146-50.
Richard E. Welch Jr., Pennsylvania History 30 (1963): 109-11.
William Appleman Williams, Canadian Historical Review 44 (1963): 346-48.
Benjamin F. Wright, Virginia Quarterly Review 38 (1962): 523-26.

volumes 1-3
Jack P. Greene, South Atlantic Quarterly 64 (1965): 403-6.

volume 2
Philip F. Detweiler, North Carolina Historical Review 40 (1963): 92-93.

volume 3
W. W. Abbot, American Historical Review 70 (1964): 186-87.
Kenneth R. Bowling, Pennsylvania History 31 (1964): 485-87.
Stuart Gerry Brown, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 88 (1964): 230-31.
William G. Carleton, Political Science Quarterly 80 (1965): 454-56.
John M. Coleman, Journal of Modern History 37 (1965): 241-42.
Noble E. Cunningham Jr., The Historian 26 (1964): 441-42.
Richard Beale Davis, Mississippi Quarterly 18 (1964-65): 55-56.
John T. Farrell, Catholic Historical Review 51 (1965): 222-23.
F. Gerald Ham, Papers of the Bibliographical Society of America 58 (1964): 309-10.
J. Edwin Hendricks, North Carolina Historical Review 41 (1964): 396-97.
Donald Jackson, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 355 (1964): 166.
Stephen G. Kurtz, Indiana Magazine of History 60 (1964): 285-86.
Leonard W. Levy, Journal of American History 51 (1964): 299-301.
David J. Mays, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 72 (1964): 365-66.
Thad W. Tate, Journal of Southern History 30 (1964): 466-68.

volumes 3-4
Merrill Jensen, Wisconsin Magazine of History 49 (1966): 341.

volumes 3-5
C. Page Smith, Canadian Historical Review 49 (1968): 295.

volumes 3-10
Linda K. Kerber, William and Mary Quarterly 35 (1978): 147-55.

volume 4
W. W. Abbot, American Historical Review 74 (1968): 709-10.
Stuart Gerry Brown, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 90 (1966): 128.
William G. Carleton, Political Science Quarterly 81 (1966): 453-54.
Jacob E. Cooke, Pennsylvania History 33 (1966): 520-22.
John T. Farrell, Catholic Historical Review 54 (1968): 535.
J. Edwin Hendricks, North Carolina Historical Review 43 (1966): 94-95.
Donald Jackson, Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 362 (1965): 200-201.
Adrienne Koch, American Scholar 34 (1965): 660, 662, 664, 666, 668.
David J. Mays, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 73 (1965): 494-96.
Paul L. Murphy, Journal of Modern History 38 (1966): 198-99.
Donald B. Scheick, Indiana Magazine of History 61 (1965): 393-94.

volumes 4-5
Richard Beale Davis, Mississippi Quarterly 21 (1967-68): 79-80.
Thad W. Tate, Journal of Southern History 34 (1968): 442-43.

volumes 4-7
Leonard W. Levy, Journal of American History 59 (1972): 115-17.

volume 5
Stuart Gerry Brown, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 92 (1968): 113-15.
Noble E. Cunningham Jr., The Historian 30 (1968): 499-500.
Merrill Jensen, Wisconsin Magazine of History 52 (1969): 280-81.
David J. Mays, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 76 (1968): 109-11.
J. R. Pole, History 53 (1968): 480.
James Morton Smith, American Historical Review 75 (1970): 1521-22.
Joseph G. Smoot, Papers of the Bibliographical Society of America 62 (1968): 149-50.

volume 6
David J. Mays, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 77 (1970): 110-12.
J. R. Pole, Journal of American Studies 5 (1971): 318-20.

volumes 6-7
Merrill Jensen, Wisconsin Magazine of History 55 (1972): 335-36.

volume 7
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 38 (1972): 128-29.

volumes 7-8
Glyndon G. Van Deusen, American Historical Review 79 (1974): 849-50.

volumes 7-10
Lester J. Cappon, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 85 (1977): 491-93.

volume 8
Clifford L. Egan, American Archivist 37 (1974): 81-82.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 39 (1973): 586-88.

volumes 8-11
James M. Banner, Jr., Journal of American History 66 (1979): 130-33.

volume 9
Edward J. Erler, Western Political Quarterly 29 (1976): 315-16.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 42 (1976): 276-77.
John A. Schutz, American Historical Review 81 (1976): 1226.

volume 10
Steven R. Boyd, American Historical Review 82 (1977): 1325.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 44 (1978): 295-97.

volume 11
Steven R. Boyd, American Historical Review 84 (1979): 255.

volumes 11-12
Richard R. Beeman, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 88 (1980): 104-5.

volumes 11-14
Richard R. Beeman, William and Mary Quarterly 43 (1986): 301-5.

volume 12
James M. Banner, Jr., Journal of American History 67 (1980): 130-31.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 46 (1980): 107-8.
Vernon O. Stumpf, North Carolina Historical Review 56 (1979): 421-22.

volumes 12-17
Michael E. Stevens, Documentary Editing (June 1992): 42-46.

volume 13
Richard Buel Jr., Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 89 (1981): 499-501.
Charles M. Harris, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 105 (1981): 497-98.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 47 (1981): 600-602.
Vernon O. Stumpf, North Carolina Historical Review 58 (1981): 401-2.

volumes 13-14
James M. Banner, Jr., Journal of American History 71 (1984): 118.

volume 14
Kenneth R. Bowling, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 92 (1984): 108-10.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 50 (1984): 115-16.
Kathryn R. Malone, Journal of the Early Republic 3 (1983): 488-89.
Michael E. Stevens, North Carolina Historical Review 60 (1983): 520.

volume 15
James M. Banner, Jr., Journal of American History 76 (1989): 248-49.
Lawrence S. Kaplan, North Carolina Historical Review 63 (1986): 263.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 52 (1986): 620-21.
Richard D. Miles, Journal of the Early Republic 6 (1986): 77-78.

volumes 15-17
Richard K. Matthews, William and Mary Quarterly 51 (1994): 172-74.

volume 16
Thom M. Armstrong, Journal of the Early Republic 10 (1990): 273-74.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 57 (1991): 319-21.
Robert W. McAhren, North Carolina Historical Review 67 (1990): 268.

volumes 16-17
Lance Banning, Journal of American History 80 (1993): 1075-76.

volume 17
Robert J. Allison, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 101 (1993): 171-72.
Thom M. Armstrong, Journal of the Early Republic 11 (1991): 567-68.
Peter V. Bergstrom, North Carolina Historical Review 69 (1992): 107-8.
Sydney Hart, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 117 (1993): 209-13.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 59 (1993): 121-22.
Jack Rakove, American Journal of Legal History 36 (1992): 396-98.