volume 1
James M. Banner, Jr., Journal of American History 76 (1989): 248-49.
Richard R. Beeman, William and Mary Quarterly 43 (1986): 301-5.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 51 (1985): 101-2.
Charles D. Lowery, Journal of the Early Republic 4 (1984): 331-32.
William Stinchcomb, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 93 (1985): 350-51.

volume 2
Doron Ben-Atar, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 119 (1995): 133-35.
Peter V. Bergstrom, North Carolina Historical Review 70 (1993): 343-44.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 60 (1994): 379-80.
Charles D. Lowery, Journal of the Early Republic 13 (1993): 271-72.

volumes 2-4
Stuart Leibiger, William and Mary Quarterly 59 (2002): 319-25.

volume 3
Peter V. Bergstrom, North Carolina Historical Review 73 (1996): 497-98.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 63 (1997): 647-49.
Charles D. Lowery, Journal of the Early Republic 16 (1996): 676-77.
Paul Douglas Newman, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 120 (1996): 381-83.
David Sloan, Louisiana History 38 (1997): 486-88.

volume 4
Peter V. Bergstrom, North Carolina Historical Review 70 (1993): 343-44.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 68 (2002): 160-62.
Paul Douglas Newman, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 126 (2002): 132-34.
Carl J. Richard, Louisiana History 42 (2001): 361-63.
David Sloan, Journal of the Early Republic 22 (1996): 133-35.

volume 5
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 71 (2005): 877-79.
Paul David Nelson, South Carolina Historical Magazine 107 (2006): 57-59.

volume 6
David Serxner, North Carolina Historical Review 86 (2009): 351-52.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 77 (2011): 693-95.

volume 7
Dickson D. Bruce Jr., Journal of Southern History 79 (2013): 698-700.
Kevin R. C. Gutzman, Journal of American History 99 (2013): 1224-25.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of the Early Republic 33 (2013): 763-69.
William Pencak, New York History 93 (2012): 246-48.

volume 8
Sandra Moats, Journal of Southern History 85 (2019): 429-31.

volume 9
Sandra Moats, Journal of Southern History 85 (2019): 900-901.

volume 11
Andrew J. B. Fagal, Scholarly Editing 39 (2022).
Lawrence Peskin, Journal of Southern History 89 (2023): 346-47.