volume 1
James M. Banner, Jr., Journal of American History 76 (1989): 248-49.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 54 (1988): 325.
Kathryn R. Malone, Virginia Magazine of History and Biography 95 (1987): 504-5.
Eugene R. Sheridan, Journal of the Early Republic 7 (1987): 305-7.
Ene Sirvet, North Carolina Historical Review 65 (1988): 114-15.
Mary K. Bonsteel Tachau, Louisiana History 29 (1988): 98-100.

volume 2
Doron Ben-Atar, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 119 (1995): 133-35.
Peter V. Bergstrom, North Carolina Historical Review 71 (1994): 136.
Warren M. Billings, Louisiana History 36 (1995): 232-34.
Eugene R. Sheridan, Journal of the Early Republic 14 (1994): 132-33.

volume 3
John M. Belohlavek, Journal of the Early Republic 15 (1995): 677-78.
Peter V. Bergstrom, North Carolina Historical Review 72 (1995): 510.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 62 (1996): 572-73.
Carl J. Richard, Louisiana History 37 (1996): 374-76.
James Roger Sharp, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 121 (1997): 135-36.

volume 4
Kenneth R. Bowling, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 123 (1999): 109-10.
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 67 (2001): 839-40.
James Roger Sharp, Journal of the Early Republic 19 (1999): 525-30.

volumes 4-5
Stuart Leibiger, William and Mary Quarterly 59 (2002): 319-25.

volume 5
Juliana Boucher, North Carolina Historical Review 79 (2002): 382-83.
Stuart Leibiger, Journal of the Early Republic 22 (2002): 320-24.
Paul Douglas Newman, Pennsylvania Magazine of History and Biography 126 (2002): 132-34.

volumes 5-6
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 71 (2005): 877-79.

volume 6
David Serxner, North Carolina Historical Review 80 (2003): 377.

volume 7
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of Southern History 74 (2008): 434-35.

volume 8
Aaron Scott Crawford, North Carolina Historical Review 86 (2009): 349-50.

volumes 8-9
Ralph Ketcham, Journal of the Early Republic 33 (2013): 763-69.

volume 9
Kevin Butterfield, Journal of Southern History 79 (2013): 163-64.
William Pencak, New York History 93 (2012): 246-48.

volume 10
Sarah A. Morgan Smith, New York History 96 (2015): 156-59.

volumes 10-11
Kevin Butterfield, Journal of Southern History 85 (2019): 152-54.