The Society for Military History annually recognizes academic excellence by awarding the Moncado Prize to authors of the four best articles published in their Journal of Military History in the previous year. Papers of James Madison editor in chief J. C. A. Stagg received a 2015 Moncado Prize for his article "Freedom and Subordination: Disciplinary Problems in the U.S. Army during the War of 1812," Journal of Military History 78 (2014): 537-74.
"This essay examines the general court martial case files for enlisted men in the War of 1812. The defendants were a reasonably representative cross section of the enlisted men, desertion was the most frequent offense, and mistreatment by officers was the most common motive for deserting. Most defendants proclaimed their innocence, but guilt and conviction were invariably the outcome in their trials. Officers struggled to find effective punishments. The abolition of corporal punishment by the lash in 1812 reduced the army's disciplinary options, resulting in an increasing recourse to the death penalty. The army, however, shrank from executing all the condemned" (abstract, ibid., 537).
Arthur S. Link Prize
The Papers of James Madison: Secretary of State Series, Vol. 2, was awarded the 1996 Arthur S. Link Prize from The Society for Historians of American Foreign Relations.
This prize, awarded at the 1996 annual meeting of the American Historical Association, "recognizes not only the high level of scholarship and erudition present in the publication of the James Madison papers, but the overall contribution to history." (Pictured above, left to right, are J. C. A. Stagg, editor in chief of the Papers of James Madison; Emily Rosenberg, president of SHAFR; Mary A. Hackett, editor of the prize-winning volume; and Alan Spetter, secretary/treasurer of SHAFR.)
Outstanding Academic Books for 1996
Senior associate editor David B. Mattern's Benjamin Lincoln and the American Revolution (available from the University of South Carolina Press) was selected for the CHOICE list of Outstanding Academic Books for 1996.
"In this definitive biography of one of America's most important but least known Revolutionary War generals, . . . Mattern tells the life story of Benjamin Lincoln, a prosperous farmer who left the comfort of his Massachusetts home to become a national hero in America's struggle for independence. Mattern's account of the citizen-soldier who served as George Washington's second-in-command at Yorktown and as secretary at war from 1781 to 1783 revisits the challenges, sacrifices, triumphs, and defeats that shaped Lincoln's evolution from affluent middle-aged family man to pillar of a dynamic republic. In addition to offering new insights into leadership during the Revolutionary period, Lincoln's life so mirrored his times that it provides an opportunity to tell the tale of the American Revolution in a fresh, compelling way" (jacket copy).